Traitors (Spoilers Everywhere)

Les_Zeppelin · January 27, 2024, 12:06am

This is what chatGPT said earlier:

chatGPT:

Players:

Evie (Faithful)

Harry (Traitor)

Andrew (Traitor)

Jas (Faithful)

Molly (Faithful)

Facts and Strategies:

Evie will be voted out in the first round.

Molly votes for Andrew until he leaves, then for Jas. She never votes for Harry.

Jas distrusts Andrew and will insist on voting if he remains. He distrusts Harry but prioritizes voting out Andrew.

If Harry and Andrew (the traitors) vote for two different faithfuls, and the faithfuls vote for Andrew, in a re-vote scenario, Harry will switch his vote to Andrew, and Andrew will vote for Harry.

Voting Scenarios and Outcomes:

First Round:

Evie is voted out.

Remaining Players: Harry, Andrew, Jas, Molly

Second Round:

Molly votes for Andrew.

Jas votes for Andrew.

Harry and Andrew (traitors) could vote for either Jas or Molly. But since Jas is suspicious of Andrew, let’s assume they both vote for Jas.

Possible Votes:

Andrew: 2 votes (from Molly and Jas)

Jas: 2 votes (from Harry and Andrew)

In Case of a Tie:

Harry switches his vote to Andrew.

Andrew votes for Harry.

Outcome of the Second Round:

Andrew gets voted out (3 votes: Molly, Jas, Harry).

Remaining Players: Harry, Jas, Molly

Third Round:

Molly now votes for Jas (as per her strategy).

Jas votes for Harry.

Harry votes for Jas.

Votes:

Jas: 2 votes (from Molly and Harry)

Harry: 1 vote (from Jas)

Outcome of the Third Round:

Jas gets voted out.

Final Players: Harry, Molly

The game would end here. Since Harry (a traitor) is still in the game, the traitors win.

Conclusion:

Given the strategies and behaviors of the players as outlined, the traitors (Harry and Andrew) have a strong chance of winning, with Harry likely being the remaining traitor at the end.

You

in how many scenarios does harry win in?

ChatGPT

ChatGPT

To determine the number of scenarios in which Harry wins, we need to consider the different voting outcomes based on the player behaviors and strategies you’ve provided. Harry wins if he remains in the game when it ends. Let’s break down the scenarios:

Fixed Outcomes:

First Round: Evie is voted out.

Second Round: Assuming Molly and Jas vote for Andrew and the traitors (Harry and Andrew) vote for Jas, this leads to a tie. In a re-vote, Harry will vote out Andrew.

Variable Outcomes After Second Round:

Remaining Players: Harry, Jas, Molly

Third Round:

If Molly votes for Jas and Harry votes for Jas, Jas will be voted out.

If Jas votes for Harry, it doesn’t change the outcome as Molly doesn’t vote for Harry.

Conclusion:

Given the provided behaviors, Harry wins in all scenarios because:

In the third round, regardless of Jas’s vote, Molly’s decision to never vote for Harry ensures Harry’s survival.

After the third round, it will always be Harry and Molly left, and since Harry is a traitor, the traitors win.

Thus, in this specific setup with the given behaviors and strategies, Harry (the traitor) wins in every scenario.

Basically Molly’s inability to vote for Harry meant he was certain to win.

The only way it could’ve changed is if Molly was switchable.

Andrew had too much heat on him in any scenario and was toast no matter what happened.