If horse racing didnât exist and someone thought it up as a new form of entertainment it would never go ahead. The fact they quite often die doing it should really make more people question the whole thing.
I always love this argument. The things we just accept in modern society because they are traditions, institutions or a big part of our history despite being awful.
Imagine if circumcision wasnât a thing and you tried to sell it in 2023. Youâd almost definitely get locked up
By the same token though, deaths do occur (although not necessarily at the same frequency, Iâm not claiming to know) in other races be it F1, motorbikes (isle of man TT every year), through to sports like football (Christian Eriksen as a notable recent example of someone who nearly died on the pitch).
The difference I suppose is that humans have the agency to choose whether to be involved. Horses do not. Equally though, if horses donât have agency to choose to race, they donât have agency to choose to stand around in a field, do farm work, or pull a fancy hearse either. They can go âwildâ I suppose, whatever that means, but you wouldnât see them in this country if they did. Modern horses as they exist now have been shaped by hundreds of years of human input. To some extent if you donât want them racing, you might not want them anywhere. Whether thatâs a shame or not is a different question howeverâŚ
Finally, the cliched line âat least they died doing something they lovedâ gets trotted out in relation to humans. Why not for horses?
I remember that discussion coming up with the mother of my first kid.
We were chatting about things relating to customs etc around babies (think christenings etc) and the topic of circumcision came up and she asked my thoughts⌠I was a bit flabbergasted, thinking oh god, maybe sheâs in favour of it. She wasnât, but wanted to know my stance. She probably could have figured it out herself tbh.
Anyhow, thinking about my penis aside. I just canât believe youâd voluntarily have a surgery performed on an infant, let alone their genitals.
Comical. Iâm sure they love having a child sized adult strapped to their backs with a whip and being made to run with all their might, while jumping over dangerously massive bushes. When was the last time three people died in one game of football? The Olympics has equestrian events for sport, with nothing like the Grand National in it. Of course there are lots of thing horses can do than be used as pawns in a purely money making, built on betting âsportâ.
To be clear I meant that comment to be tongue in cheek and devils advocatey. But I think youâre missing the point - if horses arenât being raced, we are still choosing for them what they are going to do instead. How do we know that what we choose is an improvement?
I believe racehorses are treated pretty well in the main. Better than some farmyard nag?
Itâs one of those things where society makes it seem so normal but when you look at it from a rational standpoint itâs fucking insane. Parents decide to remove some skin from a infants genitalia because ofâŚ? God? God makes us but then wants us to remove a bit of what he made because reasons? Itâs mad
There are medical reasons for it - risk of infection in young children etc. It feels rarer in the UK because the religious reasons are much less common compared to the US where it seems to just be done as standard regardless
I know someone who had to have a circumcision for medical reasons. The numbers are incredibly low on that front
The arguments around cleanliness are bullshit. If you can keep your dick clean then youâre just gross in general. A circumcision isnât going to help that
Anyway this segue isnât the point. We were debating socially accepted things that wouldnât be accepted by society if they were created in 2023. Circumcision for no reason it a perfect example